Jump to content

Tommy Maric

  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Tommy Maric

  1. So is there any recourse when a seller is just lying on a response to a review? After reading this and my post sale interaction with said seller I changed my grade which then got me an email saying I was banned from his store, however in his response he just copied and pasted the same response he gave to the gentleman above. I never asked for shipping cost upfront. Apparently expecting things to be CGC quality means when I get a VF/NM book I should expect that the centerfold may be detached at a staple, or that there is heavy foxing on the entire book inside and out that is not disclosed, and also tape pulls and tape on the cover that isn't disclosed. I don't even get the argument it seems to just out that his grading will not be good. I expect if you say something is VF or NM that it should be in the vicinity of that grade, not sure how CGC quality comes into this, wasn't buying slabbed books, Overstreet existed with grading standards before CGC.
  2. Interesting, I had a similar experience with the same seller. Most books were not even close to the listed condition, like NM with detached covers and heavy foxing that wasn't disclosed or heavy tanning, and then wasn't pleased when I wanted to return most as if somehow I was being too picky. He did take the returns and reimburse me with the shipping, but just made it a huge headache for us both by over grading so bad. Based on all the great reviews I was shocked when I got the books. Also brings me up to the character limit on reviews, doesn't give enough space to explain a complicated situation when I want to be fair and list the good and the bad. I could have just listed the bad but didn't think that'd be fair.
  3. Not sure what the issue is, I looked at my profile and everything is there, also I've received plenty of emails from other sellers before.
  • Create New...